Marginal Product vs Average Product
Marginal Product and Average Product are two Production & Costs concepts in AP Economics that students often mix up. Marginal Product is the additional output produced by adding one more unit of a variable input, holding all other inputs constant. Average Product is the total output produced per unit of a variable input, typically labor. Here is how they compare side by side.
It is calculated as the change in total product divided by the change in the variable input. Marginal product typically rises at first due to increased efficiency, then falls due to the law of diminishing marginal returns.
It is found by dividing total product by the quantity of the variable input used. Average product rises when marginal product is above it and falls when marginal product is below it.
Marginal vs Average Product: The Pull Relationship on One Labor Table
| Marginal Product | Average Product | |
|---|---|---|
| Reading a value of 10 at three workers | The third worker alone added 10 units to total output | The three workers made 30 units between them, 10 apiece on average, though only the third actually added 10 |
| How the table is read | A change in total product divided by a change in labor, so it sits between two rows | Total product divided by the labor level, so it sits on a single row |
| On the total product curve | The slope at a point | The slope of a ray from the origin to that point |
| Which peaks first | Earlier, and its fall marks the start of diminishing marginal returns | Later, exactly where marginal product crosses it |
| Can it turn negative | Yes, when an extra worker reduces total output | No, it stays positive while total output is positive |
| Cost curve it mirrors | Marginal cost, since marginal cost equals the wage divided by marginal product | Average variable cost, since average variable cost equals the wage divided by average product |
A five-worker table shows marginal product turning down while average product is still at its peak
Suppose total product runs 0, 8, 20, 30, 36, 38 as labor goes from zero to five workers. Marginal product is then 8, 12, 10, 6, 2. Average product is 8, 10, 10, 9, and 7.6. Marginal product peaks at the second worker and falls from there, so diminishing marginal returns begin with the third worker. Average product is still at its maximum at that third worker and only falls at the fourth. That one-hire gap is where most errors live. Diminishing marginal returns is a statement about marginal product turning down, not about average product turning down, and the two events happen at different points in the table. Notice what else happens at the third worker: marginal product equals average product, both at 10, and average product holds flat at its maximum instead of rising or falling. The rule generalizes. While the last worker produces more than the running average, the average is pulled up. When the last worker produces less, the average is pulled down. When the two are equal, the average does not move.
The pull rule is the arithmetic of a grade average, which is why it has no exceptions
Marginal product relates to average product the way a new test score relates to a course average. Score above your average and the average rises, score below it and the average falls, score exactly at it and the average holds still. Nothing about production is required for this result, since it follows from how averages work. The consequence for the exam is strict: marginal product must cross average product at average product's maximum, never before it, never after it, and never at marginal product's own peak. A graph showing the two curves peaking together is wrong, and so is one where marginal product cuts through the rising portion of average product. When you sketch these curves under time pressure, draw marginal product first, put its peak well to the left, then draw average product rising until it meets the falling marginal product curve and turning down at that intersection.
Each product curve becomes a cost curve once you divide the wage by it
Set the wage at $60 per worker and the same table becomes a cost table. At three workers, average product is 10 units, so average variable cost is the wage divided by average product, $60 over 10, or $6 per unit. Check it the long way: three workers cost $180 and produce 30 units, which is $6 per unit. The third worker's marginal product is also 10 units, so marginal cost across that range is $60 over 10, again $6. Because average variable cost equals the wage over average product, average variable cost reaches its minimum exactly where average product reaches its maximum. The same inversion links marginal product to marginal cost. This is why the product curves and the cost curves are mirror images of each other: the product curves rise then fall, the cost curves fall then rise, and their turning points line up. If a question gives you a product table and asks for average variable cost, dividing the wage by average product is faster than rebuilding the cost column.
Frequently asked questions
Do diminishing marginal returns begin at marginal product's peak or average product's peak?
Diminishing marginal returns begin the moment marginal product starts falling, which is one hire past marginal product's peak. Average product is often still rising at that point, so a table can show diminishing returns already underway while output per worker keeps improving. In the sequence 8, 12, 10, 6, 2, diminishing returns begin with the third worker, whose marginal product of 10 sits below the second worker's 12, while average product does not fall until the fourth worker. Pointing at average product's peak is a frequent lost point.
Can marginal product be negative while average product stays positive?
Marginal product turns negative whenever an extra worker actually reduces total output, and average product stays positive as long as total output is above zero. A sixth worker who crowds the kitchen might cut total product from 38 units to 35, giving a marginal product of negative 3, while average product is still 35 divided by 6, about 5.8 units. A firm would never hire into that range, since it pays a wage for output that shrinks, but the arithmetic is entirely consistent and exam tables sometimes include the row to test you.
Why do marginal product and average product cross at average product's maximum?
Marginal product crosses average product at the maximum because that crossing is what a maximum means for an average. While the incoming unit is above the average, the average must still be rising. While the incoming unit is below it, the average must be falling. The turning point is the single moment at which the two are equal. The same logic makes marginal cost cut average total cost at its minimum, so learning it once covers several graphs on the exam.
Live Production Costs graph. Drag the curves, or open the full version.
Related comparisons
Get AP Econ exam tips in your inbox
Occasional emails with study tips, new interactive graphs, and exam-season reminders. Free, no spam.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. Read our privacy policy.
Keep track of what you have studied
A free EconLearn account adds progress tracking, your quiz history, and achievements. Studying here is free either way, and there is nothing to pay for as a student.
Create a free accountAlready have one? Sign in
Last updated