How to Use the Twin Deficits Identity
The saving identity says (S − I) + (T − G) = net exports, so a budget deficit must show up as lower net exports unless private saving rises or investment falls.
The Twin Deficits formula
Calculator
Enter saving, investment, taxes and government spending to get the net exports the national saving identity implies.
What households and firms save out of disposable income.
Spending on new capital, housing and inventories inside the country.
Tax revenue minus transfer payments and subsidies, not gross tax collections.
Government purchases of goods and services.
The two internal balances leave −$300B, so the country runs a trade deficit and borrows the difference from abroad.
- Private saving minus investment
- $200B
- Government budget balance
- −$500B
- National saving
- $2,700B
- Twin deficits check
- Twin deficits
Private saving covers domestic investment with $200B to spare, which is the private half of the identity.
Spending beats revenue by $500B, so the government is a net borrower.
Private saving plus the government balance is $2,700B, and subtracting investment gives the same net exports figure.
Hold saving and investment steady and every extra dollar of budget deficit has to come out of net exports, because the identity has nowhere else to put it.
How to calculate Twin Deficits, step by step
- 1Find the private balance. Subtract domestic investment from private saving. A positive figure means households and firms save more than the country invests at home.
- 2Find the government balance. Subtract government spending from net tax revenue. A negative figure is a budget deficit, which is the government saving less than nothing.
- 3Add the two balances. Their sum equals net exports. This comes straight out of national income accounting, so it holds in every year by construction.
- 4Read the twin result. Hold private saving and investment steady and a wider budget deficit passes through one for one into a smaller trade balance.
- 5Check the escape routes. The pass-through breaks whenever private saving rises or investment falls at the same time, which is why the twin pattern is a tendency rather than a rule.
Worked example: Twin Deficits
Private saving is $3,200 billion, domestic investment is $3,000 billion, net tax revenue is $3,500 billion, and government spending is $4,000 billion. The private balance is 3,200 − 3,000 = $200 billion and the government balance is 3,500 − 4,000 = −$500 billion, a budget deficit. Net exports = 200 + (−500) = −$300 billion, so the trade deficit sits alongside the budget deficit. The cross-check agrees: national saving = 3,200 + (−500) = $2,700 billion, and 2,700 − 3,000 = −$300 billion.
Twin Deficits questions
Does the identity prove that budget deficits cause trade deficits?
No. The identity is accounting and always balances, while the twin deficits hypothesis adds the causal claim. A budget deficit can just as well be matched by higher private saving or lower investment instead of by weaker net exports.
How would the causal link work?
Government borrowing raises the demand for loanable funds and pushes the real interest rate up. Higher rates draw in foreign financial capital, the currency appreciates, exports become dearer abroad and imports cheaper at home, so net exports fall.
What if private saving rises alongside the deficit?
Then the two balances offset and net exports need not move at all. That is the Ricardian equivalence case, where households save more because they expect the taxes that will repay the borrowing.
Which taxes belong in T?
Net taxes, meaning total tax revenue minus transfer payments and subsidies. Using gross tax revenue overstates the government balance and breaks the identity.
Get AP Econ exam tips in your inbox
Occasional emails with study tips, new interactive graphs, and exam-season reminders. Free, no spam.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. Read our privacy policy.
Keep track of what you have studied
A free EconLearn account adds progress tracking, your quiz history, and achievements. Studying here is free either way, and there is nothing to pay for as a student.
Create a free accountAlready have one? Sign in
Last updated