Barter
What is Barter?
Barter is the direct exchange of goods and services for other goods and services without using money.
It requires a double coincidence of wants, each party must want what the other offers, which makes trade slow and inefficient. Money solves this problem by serving as a universal medium of exchange.
Barter: a worked example
Three traders meet. Maya bakes bread and wants shoes, Owen makes shoes and wants a haircut, and Priya cuts hair and wants bread. Check every pair and none of them can trade, because no pair holds what the other wants while wanting what the other holds. The deal closes only if all three meet at once and pass goods around the circle. Now count prices. Barter needs an exchange ratio for every pair of goods, which is n times n minus 1, all over 2. Five goods means 10 posted ratios. Forty goods means 40 times 39 over 2, or 780 ratios a trader would have to keep straight. Introduce money and each good carries one price, so 40 goods means 40 prices. Cutting 780 numbers down to 40 is why no complex economy has ever run on barter.
The mistake students make with barter
On free response questions students answer that barter is inefficient and stop there, or they credit money's store of value function with solving the problem. The specific failure in barter is the double coincidence of wants, and the function that repairs it is medium of exchange. The exploding count of exchange ratios is repaired by the unit of account function instead. Store of value matters for carrying purchasing power across time, not for closing the trade in front of you. Name the barter problem, name the matching function, then say why the trade now happens.
Barter questions
What is the double coincidence of wants?
The double coincidence of wants is the condition barter requires: each trader must hold exactly what the other wants while wanting exactly what the other holds. A dentist who wants a bicycle has to find a bicycle maker with a toothache, and if the bicycle maker's teeth are fine, the trade dies. Search costs climb as the number of goods and traders grows, so gains both sides would happily take go unrealized. Money ends the requirement, because a seller takes it without wanting anything the buyer produces.
Why is barter inefficient?
Barter drains time into hunting for a partner, time that could have gone into production. Indivisibility bites next, since a farmer trading a cow for a shirt cannot hand over one sleeve's worth of cow, and many goods spoil before a match turns up. Both frictions shrink specialization, because a worker will not narrow down to a single craft when the output is this awkward to exchange. The economy ends up producing a wider and worse assortment of goods than it could.
Do people still use barter?
Barter survives in pockets where money is scarce or unwanted: prisoners trading rations, neighbors swapping babysitting hours, firms exchanging advertising space for hotel rooms, and governments settling trade in goods when currency is restricted. Each case works because the group is small enough that finding a matching partner is easy. None of them scale, which is the point the AP course wants made. Barter is workable in a village and impossible in a national economy.
Related terms
Common comparisons
Get AP Econ exam tips in your inbox
Occasional emails with study tips, new interactive graphs, and exam-season reminders. Free, no spam.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. Read our privacy policy.
Keep track of what you have studied
A free EconLearn account adds progress tracking, your quiz history, and achievements. Studying here is free either way, and there is nothing to pay for as a student.
Create a free accountAlready have one? Sign in
Last updated