Consumer Confidence Index vs Purchasing Managers' Index
Consumer Confidence Index and Purchasing Managers' Index are two Economic Indicators & Data concepts in AP Economics that students often mix up. The consumer confidence index measures how optimistic households feel about the economy and their finances. Purchasing Managers' Index readings come from monthly surveys of supply managers, where a value above 50 means expansion and below 50 means contraction. Here is how they compare side by side.
Because consumer spending is the largest part of GDP, confidence helps predict future spending. Rising confidence often signals stronger demand ahead; falling confidence can foreshadow a slowdown. It is a leading indicator.
Purchasing Managers' Index surveys ask supply managers at hundreds of firms whether new orders, output, employment, supplier delivery times and inventories are better, the same, or worse than the previous month. Each question becomes a diffusion index, and the headline PMI averages those components. The dividing line is 50: above 50, more respondents report improvement than deterioration, so the sector is expanding, and below 50 it is contracting. Distance from 50 measures how widespread the change is, not how large it is, so a reading of 55 says growth is broad, not that output grew 5 percent. In the United States the Institute for Supply Management publishes manufacturing and services versions, and S&P Global produces comparable indexes for many countries, which makes PMI one of the earliest cross-country reads on the cycle each month.
Consumer Confidence vs the PMI: Who Is Being Surveyed, and About What
| Consumer Confidence Index | Purchasing Managers' Index | |
|---|---|---|
| Who answers | Households | Purchasing managers at manufacturing and service firms |
| What they are asked | How they feel about jobs, income and business conditions | Whether orders, output, employment and delivery times rose or fell |
| How answers become a number | Positive answers scored against a reference period | A diffusion index: share reporting higher, plus half the share reporting no change |
| The neutral reading | None, so the level only means something against its own history | 50, the line where increases and decreases cancel |
| What it tracks best | Large household purchases, and the link to spending is loose | Near-term output in factories and service firms |
| Distance from actual transactions | Reports a mood, which can diverge from spending for long stretches | Reports decisions already made, with orders attached |
A diffusion index is not an average, which is why fifty is the line
The arithmetic behind the manufacturing survey is simple and constantly misread. Managers are asked whether output was higher, the same, or lower than last month. Suppose 40 percent say higher, 45 percent say no change and 15 percent say lower. The diffusion index adds the share reporting an increase to half the share reporting no change, so it reads 40 plus 22.5, which is 62.5. The next month brings 20 percent higher, 45 percent the same and 35 percent lower, giving 20 plus 22.5, which is 42.5. Fifty is neutral because that is the value you get when increases and decreases exactly offset. Two consequences follow. First, the index says nothing about magnitude. A month in which every expanding firm grew by a sliver and every shrinking firm collapsed still reads above fifty. Second, a fall from 62.5 to 55 is not a contraction, it is slower expansion, because 55 is still above the line. A household confidence index is built on a different principle, scoring answers against a reference period, so it has no neutral value at all. Both series appear in composite forecasting measures, described at /glossary/leading-economic-indicators.
What people say and what they buy are two different series
The surveys also differ in how close the respondent sits to a transaction. A purchasing manager reporting that new orders rose is reporting a decision that has already been made, with a purchase order behind it. A household reporting that it feels worse about the year ahead is reporting a mood, and the distance between mood and spending can be large and can stay large for a long time. Sentiment often sags while spending holds up, especially when the thing depressing the mood is a price everybody sees on a sign, such as fuel, rather than a change in income. That is why household confidence is read for direction rather than level, and why analysts separate the part of the survey covering conditions now from the part covering the next six months, since the second moves earlier and carries more of the forecasting value. The practical rule is to treat the manager survey as an early reading on output and the household survey as a check on whether demand is likely to hold, then confirm both against what households actually spent, which is reported at /glossary/retail-sales.
Frequently asked questions
What does a PMI reading of 55 mean?
It means more of the firms surveyed reported improving conditions than reported worsening ones, so the sector is expanding. It says nothing about how fast, because the index counts the direction of each firm's answer rather than the size of the change.
Is consumer confidence a good predictor of spending?
It is a weak one on its own. Confidence and spending move together over long stretches, but households frequently report gloom while continuing to buy, so the survey is more useful as an early warning about big purchases such as cars and appliances than as a forecast of total consumption.
What is a diffusion index?
A diffusion index summarizes how widely a change has spread rather than how large it is, by counting the share of respondents reporting an increase and adding half the share reporting no change. Fifty marks the point where increases and decreases balance, so readings above it mean growth is spreading and readings below it mean the opposite.
Live Business Cycle graph. Drag the curves, or open the full version.
Get AP Econ exam tips in your inbox
Occasional emails with study tips, new interactive graphs, and exam-season reminders. Free, no spam.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. Read our privacy policy.
Keep track of what you have studied
A free EconLearn account adds progress tracking, your quiz history, and achievements. Studying here is free either way, and there is nothing to pay for as a student.
Create a free accountAlready have one? Sign in
Last updated