Crowding In
What is Crowding In?
Crowding in is when government spending raises private investment, the opposite of crowding out, typically during a recession with idle resources.
In a deep recession, expansionary fiscal policy can boost demand, output, and incomes without driving up interest rates much, because savings are ample and resources are idle. The resulting rise in sales and optimism encourages firms to invest, so public spending 'crowds in' rather than crowds out private investment. The accelerator effect (higher output raising desired capital) reinforces this. Whether crowding in or crowding out dominates depends on how close the economy is to full employment.
Crowding In: a worked example
An economy sits well below full employment, with idle factories and high unemployment. Congress raises spending by $50 billion. With an MPC of 0.75 the spending multiplier is 1/(1 - 0.75) = 4, so real GDP rises by 4 × $50 billion = $200 billion. Firms here add capital equal to 10% of any increase in annual sales, so desired investment rises by 0.10 × $200 billion = $20 billion. The extra government borrowing does lift the real interest rate, but only from 3.0% to 3.1%, because unused saving is plentiful. If firms cut investment by $20 billion for each percentage point rise in the real rate, that 0.1 point increase trims just 0.1 × $20 billion = $2 billion. Net change in investment = $20 billion - $2 billion = +$18 billion. Private investment rose alongside government spending.
The mistake students make with crowding in
A common slip is drawing crowding in by shifting the supply of loanable funds right, on the reasoning that government spending pours money into the market. Deficit spending adds to the demand for loanable funds, not to its supply, so that diagram on its own can never produce crowding in. Crowding in belongs on the investment demand schedule, which moves outward when stronger sales raise the expected return on new capital at every interest rate. Investment can climb even while the real rate climbs, because the schedule shifted outward at the same time. Name the schedule that moved and why, or the answer reads as a contradiction.
Crowding In questions
Does crowding in mean interest rates fall?
Crowding in does not require falling interest rates. Government borrowing still adds to the demand for loanable funds, so the real rate usually ticks up a little. Crowding in works through a different channel: higher spending raises sales and capacity utilization, firms expect stronger future demand, and the investment those expectations trigger outweighs the small discouragement from a slightly higher rate. Rates can even fall later if recovery lifts incomes and national saving enough to shift the supply of loanable funds right.
When is crowding in more likely than crowding out?
Crowding in is most likely in a deep recession with idle factories, high unemployment, and ample unused saving, where extra demand raises output rather than the price level and the real interest rate barely moves. Crowding out dominates near full employment, where the economy cannot produce much more, government borrowing competes directly with firms for a fixed pool of saving, and the real rate rises enough to cancel private projects. A strong exam answer names the starting position, not just the policy.
What is the accelerator effect in crowding in?
The accelerator effect describes firms raising desired capital when output and sales rise, since producing more goods requires more machines and buildings. Under crowding in, fiscal stimulus lifts real GDP through the multiplier, the higher sales make previously marginal projects worth funding, and investment spending climbs as a result. The accelerator makes investment respond to the quantity of output sold, not only to the interest rate, which is why public spending can pull private investment up with it.
Related terms
Common comparisons
Get AP Econ exam tips in your inbox
Occasional emails with study tips, new interactive graphs, and exam-season reminders. Free, no spam.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. Read our privacy policy.
Keep track of what you have studied
A free EconLearn account adds progress tracking, your quiz history, and achievements. Studying here is free either way, and there is nothing to pay for as a student.
Create a free accountAlready have one? Sign in
Last updated